Field note / separate the checks

A reachable address does not prove the portal works.

Name resolution maps a name to an address. IP reachability tests a path. A service check asks whether the intended application is available at its protocol and port.

Compare three observations

CheckWhat this exercise establishes
Probe 10.20.20.80A computed forward and return path to the web endpoint.
Resolve portal.exampleA reachable configured resolver, its enabled DNS service and the A record 10.20.20.80.
Verify serviceResolution, bidirectional reachability and an enabled web service listening on TCP 443.

Create a failure after the repair

First repair the gateway to 10.10.10.1. Turn off the DNS service and probe the web IP. The path still works, but resolving the name fails. Restore DNS, then change the web listening port to 8443. Name resolution succeeds while the ticket's TCP 443 service requirement fails.

In the real world, an ICMP reply alone does not prove a TCP service is listening, and ICMP filtering can prevent ping replies while another service works. The web exercise's probe is a computed path check, not a real ICMP implementation. Its service check does not perform a TLS handshake or fetch HTTP content.

Use evidence for each claim

RFC 1034, section 3.6 describes DNS resource records. IANA's service and port registry associates services with transports and ports; registration does not establish that a particular host runs one. The example above is original and contains no exam material.

Compare the service checks